Which Music Streaming Service Pays Artists the Most?
Music streaming has completely transformed the way we enjoy our favorite songs. Platforms like Spotify, Apple Music, and Tidal give us instant access to millions of tracks with just a few taps. But have you ever wondered how much of the money you spend on streaming services goes to the artists who create the music?
For musicians, streaming can be both a blessing and a challenge. While it allows them to reach fans worldwide, the payments they receive per stream often leave much to be desired. If you’re looking for a DJ for your corporate event, DJ Will Gill is the one to call. He has earned over 2,000 five-star reviews during his career as a DJ and Emcee.
Watch the video below to see DJ Will Gill in action on stage.
Let’s explore which streaming service pays artists best, how payouts work, and how to support your favorite musicians.
How Do Streaming Services Pay Artists?
Before we jump into specific platforms, it’s important to understand how payouts work. Music streaming services divide their revenue between the platform, record labels, publishers, and, finally, the artists themselves. Payments are typically calculated based on the number of plays or streams. This is known as the “pay-per-stream” rate.
However, these rates aren’t as straightforward as they seem. An artist’s earnings depend on the listener’s country, subscription type, and distribution deals. On average, many artists earn less than a penny per stream, which can make it difficult to make a living solely from streaming income.
Now, let’s compare the payouts and policies of some of the top streaming platforms.
Spotify
Pay-Per-Stream Rate
Spotify is the biggest music streaming platform in the world, with over 500 million users. You might expect such a large company to offer generous payouts, but that’s not the case. Spotify’s average pay-per-stream rate is between $0.003 and $0.005. This means it would take about 250 streams to earn just $1.
Key Policies
Spotify uses a “pro-rata” payment model. All subscription and ad revenue is shared based on total streams. Unfortunately, this system favors top-charting artists over smaller, independent musicians who may not get as many plays.
Controversies
Spotify has faced criticism for its low payouts and lack of transparency. Many artists feel the platform prioritizes corporate profit over fair compensation for creators.
Apple Music
Pay-Per-Stream Rate
Apple Music, with approximately 88 million subscribers, offers a slightly better deal for artists. Its pay-per-stream rate averages around $0.01 per stream. While this might not seem like much, it’s double what Spotify pays on average.
Key Policies
Unlike Spotify, Apple Music does not have a free tier. This increases the revenue available to pay artists, as all listeners are paying subscribers. Additionally, Apple claims to distribute a higher percentage of revenue directly to rights holders.
Artist-Friendly Moves
Apple Music has committed to being more transparent about its payout process. The company explains how artists earn, earning praise from the music industry.
Tidal
Pay-Per-Stream Rate
Tidal, known for its high-quality audio and artist-centric approach, offers some of the highest payouts. Its average pay-per-stream rate is between $0.012 and $0.013. While still small, this is nearly three times what Spotify pays.
Key Policies
Tidal is a favorite among artists because of its positioning as a platform “for the creators.” Tidal’s ‘Direct Artist Payouts’ sends part of your subscription to your top-streamed artist monthly. This system ensures that artists benefit more directly from their fan base.
Who Benefits Most?
Independent artists on Tidal benefit most from its high payouts and fan-friendly policies. However, Tidal’s smaller user base—it has fewer than 5 million subscribers—limits its overall impact.
Amazon Music
Pay-Per-Stream Rate
Amazon Music’s payout rates are similar to Spotify’s, averaging $0.004 per stream. While not the worst, this rate doesn’t do much to help artists earn a sustainable income.
Key Policies
Amazon Music has expanded rapidly in recent years, offering both free and paid plans. However, much like Spotify, its “pro-rata” model largely benefits artists who already dominate the charts.
Standing Out
One benefit Amazon provides is its integration with other Amazon services, such as Alexa. This makes music on Amazon Music easily accessible, which can result in more streams for artists.
YouTube Music
Pay-Per-Stream Rate
YouTube Music, part of the YouTube ecosystem, pays artists about $0.008 per stream on average. YouTube pays more than Spotify, but streams cost less due to ads.
Key Policies
YouTube Music makes it easy for independent artists to upload and monetize their music. Its large audience boosts exposure, leading to income from concerts or merchandise.
Challenges
One downside is that YouTube’s payouts depend heavily on ad revenue. This means that artists may experience significant fluctuations in earnings.
Deezer
Pay-Per-Stream Rate
Deezer, while not as well-known globally, offers competitive payouts of about $0.0064 per stream. This places it in the middle of the pack compared to other major platforms.
Key Policies
Deezer recently introduced a “User-Centric Payment System” (UCPS) in some countries. Instead of pooling all revenue, this system pays artists based on the actual listening habits of individual users. This change has been praised as a fairer alternative to the pro-rata model.
Limitations
While UCPS is promising, its limited rollout and Deezer’s smaller market share keep its impact relatively modest.
Why Are Streaming Payouts a Challenge?
Even the highest-paying platforms require millions of streams to generate significant income. For example, on Spotify, an artist would need over 300,000 streams to make $1,000. This makes it difficult for independent musicians or emerging bands to earn a sustainable income without alternative revenue streams.
Due to complex rights, artists get only a fraction of platform payouts. Record labels, songwriters, and distributors all take their share before the artist sees any money.
How You Can Support Your Favorite Artists
If you love music and want to help artists thrive, here are some ways to make a difference:
- Stream on Artist-Friendly Platforms
Consider using services like Tidal or Apple Music, which offer more generous payouts and artist-supporting features.
- Buy Their Music
Buying albums or songs directly gives artists a bigger share than streaming.
- Attend Concerts
Live performances are a major source of income for musicians. Check out local shows and support artists by buying tickets, merchandise, and more.
- Purchase Merch
Merchandise like T-shirts, posters, and vinyl records provide another way to support musicians while owning something unique.
- Spread the Word
Sharing your favorite artists’ music with friends and on social media can help grow their fan base and increase their streams.
No Streaming Service is Perfect
No streaming service is perfect, but Tidal and Apple Music offer better payouts and artist-friendly policies. However, streaming alone isn’t enough for most musicians to make a living. Buy music, attend shows, or get merchandise to help your favorite artists keep creating.